Friday, January 2, 2015

Disney's Blonde Obession

Have ethnic females been FROZEN out by Disney?  Lord knows I have grown up loving Disney theatrical features and TV shows.  When I was a kid, Walt Disney hosted Wonderful World of Color Sunday nights on NBC.  That was "Must-See TV" for youngsters.  Today, Disney is the parent company of ABC.  Last year, with the phenomenal box office success of Frozen, Elsa was such a hot new character that she seemed to eclipse Mickey Mouse, the character who put Disney on the global map.
The Oscar-winning song from Frozen, "Let It Go," seemed to replace the Oscar-winning song "Zip-A-Dee-Doo-Dah" (from 1946's Song of the South) as Disney's Magic Kingdom theme.  And ABC's.  In the last couple of months, I started to wonder if you watch an entire broadcast of Good Morning America or get through one solid hour of ABC prime time programming starting at 8pm without hearing a bit of "Let It Go."  I liked the motivational, girl power song at first -- but every single day and night, ABC?
Elsa from Frozen is Disney's new "It" girl.  Hundreds and hundreds of little females dressed as Elsa for Halloween.  On Good Morning America, Robin Roberts dressed as Elsa for Halloween.  Robin Roberts interviewed an "Elsa" at DisneyWorld for a nationally televised holiday parade special.  In the weeks leading up to Christmas, it was nice to see ABC bring back Mickey Mouse for product placement appearances.  After all, he has been the corporate logo for decades.  The Frozen ice queen got her own storyline added to ABC's Once Upon a Time.  Long blonde hair, blue dress and all.
Disney's Cinderella is one of my favorite full-length animated features from the studio's 1950s period.  The company has been retooling characters it made famous in its Golden Years.  Come March, Disney gives us CINDERELLA again.  This time, in live action form with top actresses such as Cate Blanchett and Helena Bonham Carter.
I admit that the trailer makes me want to see it.  However, something makes me curious.  I'm writing as a grown male who's not seen all the Disney animated releases of the last few years.  But I'm a grown male who's concerned about big screen images.  Two years before Frozen, Disney Studios released the Oscar-winning drama, The Help.  In that, we saw the extraordinary Viola Davis as a black maid in the 1960s tenderly saying to a privileged little blonde Southern girl, "You is kind.  You is smart.  You is important."
With the popularity of Frozen, we saw white and black females, girls and women, dressed up like blonde Elsa for Halloween.  Now we're getting a new version of Cinderella.  Just like Elsa, this Cinderella will be a young, slim, pretty blonde with a petite nose who wears a pretty blue dress.

Is there a subliminal message Disney is trying to send to our minority girls?  First of all, how come we're not seeing big screen retoolings of 1998's Asian heroine, MULAN...

....or sweet Tiana, the African American lead in 2009's THE PRINCESS AND THE FROG?

I love Helena Bonham Carter.  But let's think about this:  Viola Davis now stars as a brilliant law school professor on a hit ABC series called How To Get Away With Murder.  Disney is ABC's parent company, as I mentioned earlier.  Did anyone think to ask Viola to go fantasy glam and give her the festive -- and important -- role of the Fairy Godmother?  If not Viola, you know who I would've offered the Fairy Godmother role to?  Oprah!  For years on daytime television with her annual "Oprah's Favorite Things" edition of her talk show or the day she gave everybody in the audience a car, she really was the Fairy Godmother of daytime talk shows.  Also, it would've been fabulous to see her in a fun role and making dreams come true instead of playing another woman who gets knocked to the ground by a bigot down South -- specifically The Color Purple and now Selma.

Oprah as the Fairy Godmother would have been fabulous casting.

I grew up on a cul-de-sac block in South Central Los Angeles.  My working class family's friends and neighbors were black, Mexican and Asian.  When I was a boy, I looked for images of my world on the big screen and on TV.  Ethnic images.  My drive to be a celebrity talk show host, film reviewer and game show host on TV was fueled by the fact I didn't see us minorities do that kind of work on local and network TV when I was a kid.

Back in 1990, I met with Disney execs in L.A. about possibly hosting my own celebrity talk show for Disney's Buena Vista syndication.  I was honored to have the meetings, as I've been a longtime Disney fan.  I'm still a Disney fan.  I'm also a black male concerned about film images for minority little girls and teens.  I just want to make sure that Disney today will embrace them too and give them the feeling that they are kind, they are smart and they are important.  They don't secretly have to wish that they were slim and pretty Caucasian blondes in order to have special powers or to make their dreams come true.


  1. I agree completely with Chris Rock that Hollywood is a white industry, and a racist one. Oh they'll say it's for the bottom line, but that becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. If you spend billions promoting movies where 99% of people are white, you are contributing to the institutional racism that makes white-only movies the big money makers.
    But I believe it's worse than that. "Fantasy" and fairy tales are popular among white people because they are mostly populated with white people. I rarely read fantasy (even Game of Thrones) because most of it is all white. And I'm a white guy. Because I was lucky enough to grow up in a diverse neighborhood, so it weirds me out when someone concocts a FANTASY world, and decides "well, it would be all white. Except for those savages over there. And by the way, there'll be lots of rape. But also magic and dragons and impossible things. Because if I had a magic wand, I'd rather have dragons and super powerful white people, and rape and racism, rather than a world with no rape and racism where us white dudes aren't King Shit."
    It's more complex than that, but that is always there, because that's what entitlement and privilege do. (explains the white guy...)
    Fairy Tales seem to be the same, this fantasy never-been world where everyone was white, and magic worked. "Hey, wasn't it great back then... we had plague, but at least no people of color making us feel all guilty and shit!"
    Nostalgia isn't always terrible, but when us white folks get nostalgic, look out. It's usually for that reason.

    There are thousands of "princess" and "fairytale" stories waiting to be told, where young children can see someone who doesn't always look like Elsa, She-Wolf of Mauschwitz. Maybe they won't sell as astronomically, but neither do "Oscar Bait" movies. Disney has the scratch to give us some variety, because it's the right thing to do. It pisses me off that TV and movies (and books) seem less diverse than when I grew up. Yes, that's "what sells." Because that's what we promote.

  2. Man, I wish you had the opportunity to say all that on a network morning news program. Thank you! Thank you for that bulls-eye response.

  3. Look how long it took them to give us an African-American princess when they did The Princess and the Frog…yet we don't hear much about her.

    As a side note since you're in NYC, you really need to go see this show before it closes on the 25th of this month. It covers some of the very things you are discussing.


Starring Tom Skerritt

It opens on September 24th. The new film, EAST OF THE MOUNTAINS , stars Tom Skerritt in the lead role. The veteran actor is now in his 80s a...